Why discuss Underfloor Heating? Space heating energy constitutes a major proportion of total UK primary energy consumption – at least 60% for example in the domestic sector. Despite improvements in energy efficiency (better insulation etc) energy use in our homes is increasing.
The number of homes is increasing too and we keep our home warmer than we ever used to (average 16oC in 1990 rising to 18oC in 2004).
So how do we maintain this drive for more and more comfort whilst reducing our energy burden – is Underfloor Heating (UFH) a potential solution?
Underfloor Heating comes in two forms – wet and electric
Lets look at wet systems first – fed by the circulation of hot water through pipes under floors.
These systems warm the floor structure by conduction causing the surface to radiate heat into the space above and the primary source of heat is typically a boiler.
The boiler heats water to 40-50oC and this is distributed in plastic pipes to one or more manifolds from which loops are taken to serve areas of the building to be heated.
In a simple two-storey office for example there would be one manifold serving the GF and one for the FF each feeding UFH loops in the individual rooms on that floor.
Getting good conduction between the UFH loops and the floor structure is the key to success.
Different methods of transferring heat from the pipes are applied for different floor structures.
Pipes are usually fixed to the floor insulation and a concrete screed poured over them further to which floor tiles, carpets or other surface finishes are applied.
Where floor tiles are used heat radiates into the “treated space” at roughly 100W/m2. The design output achievable with suspended timber floors averages slightly lower at 70W/m2.
Note the use of the word radiate – UFH is more akin to radiant heating than is for example the use of radiators which are mostly convection.
Radiant heat means less rising heat lost to the roof void as convection – indeed with UFH the reverse is probably true – that is temperature inversion where the floor is hotter than the ceiling.
All of this means that the boiler operates at a lower temperature which promotes good combustion increasing efficiency.
Typically a condensing boiler serving Underfloor Heating would operate at 90% compared to 87% for the same boiler feeding radiators.
These low operating temperatures also means that UFH is the ideal partner for “renewables” such as heat pumps (where the heat exchanger carried out an air to water transfer).
Why ideal? Well, simply because these systems tend only to heat water to 40-50oC.
I like this system so much that I am currently putting an Air Source Heat Pump into my own house to replace my oil boiler.
I am lucky in that my radiators are already over-sized so they will cope with the lower flow temperature.
Pro’s for Underfloor Heating
- Lower running costs and CO2 emissions
- Optimises thermal comfort
- Enhances decor by concealing heating
- Flexible for use with renewables and CHP
- Ease of access to manifolds for maintenance
- Concealed heat emitters improve access for cleaning floors and skirtings
- Enhances property value
- Common on continent – becoming more popular in UK
- Extended warranty of up to 25 years available on pipework loops of most UFH systems
Cons – down-side of Underfloor Heating
- Slower response time
- Heat output limited to 100W/m2
- Supplementary heating may be required in small rooms & bathrooms with two external walls, small conservatories and corridors with large glazed areas
- Remains a “novel” technology, despite recent growth which tends to lead to uncompetitive pricing
- Can restrict floor finish
- Pumps can be noisy so need sound damping or remote siting to avoid nuisance to occupiers
- Deep floor required to accommodate pipework and insulation
- Not really much of an option for existing properties unless flooring is being replaced
- Risk of damaging pipework if flooring is penetrated, leading to potentially costly repair works
I have to confess I have some of this in my own home – and very effective it is too.
We installed it in a wee lean-to conservatory underneath slate tiles and have control via an Aube TH132-F floor sensor stat.
Our space is just over 6m2 so we installed a mat rated at 750W.
The thermostatic control and timed management keep running costs down to a bare minimum and I reckon an entire winter costs us £50-ish.